Do as I say, not as I do
So DeLay's father passed on in a similar fashion as Schiavo will soon according to a recent report. I understand people change views as life moves forward, but it appears to me that Mr. DeLay is an extremely unprincipled man. Here are a few excerpts:
A family tragedy that unfolded in a Texas hospital during the fall of 1988 was a private ordeal — without judges, emergency sessions of Congress or the debate raging outside Terri Schiavo's Florida hospice."The situation faced by the congressman's family was entirely different than Terri Schiavo's," said a spokesman for the majority leader, who declined requests for an interview."The only thing keeping her alive is the food and water we all need to survive. His father was on a ventilator and other machines to sustain him," said Dan Allen, DeLay's press aide.There were also these similarities: Both stricken patients were severely brain-damaged. Both were incapable of surviving without medical assistance. Both were said to have expressed a desire to be spared from being kept alive by artificial means. And neither of them had a living will.
2 Comments:
While I agree that Mr. Delay's positions seem inconsistent and I am still confused as to why he has become the self-appointed moral judge of the actions taken in the Schiavo case, I don't think I would call him unprincipled based solely on what we think is an inconsistency between what he did for his father and what he is doing now. Thanks to Professor Kaveny's "Law and Ethics at the End of Life," I learned that most Christian traditions (including Catholicism) do not consider the insertion of a feeding tube to be an "extraordinary measure" to keep someone alive. Taking someone off (or never putting them on) life support and denying them food and water is distinct in their eyes. The former is permitted and the latter is not. I don't agree, but I think the distinction is at the heart of this case.
I'm with you Abe, this has prompted me to make sure I have a living will.
If you were smart enough to think for yourself then people like Mr. Delay wouldn't feel compelled to think for you. Long Live W.
Post a Comment
<< Home